A person carries a harvest basket past a farmhouse and kitchen garden in open countryside

Best States for Homesteading: What to Look For Before You Buy

Editorial team, smallholdingnotes.com · · 6 min read

There is no honest single ranking of “best states”

The best states for homesteading, as a search phrase, usually want a podium. A podium is the wrong tool. A state that is kind to a dryland grain farm may be a poor fit for a woodland smallholding. A state with a long growing season can still have counties that forbid the animals you wanted, or a water rule that will not support the garden you drew. The useful work is a checklist, then a county-level look, then a walk on the actual land.

This is not a ranking, and it does not invent scores, land prices, or tax rates. For official help, use USDA beginning-farmer pages such as farmers.gov, the directory of land-grant universities and Extension partners, and the state and county sites that actually regulate wells, septic systems, zoning, and livestock. If you are looking at homesteading in Washington state, or in any other named state, those local official pages matter more than a national list.

Nothing here is legal, tax, or real-estate advice. A purchase contract is a poor place to experiment.

The questions that should sit in the columns, not the state nicknames

Water: rights, wells, irrigation districts, drought rules, and the cost of getting a household supply that is legal and reliable. In some places, a pretty creek on the listing photo is not a water right you may use. Ask official offices, and put answers in writing.

Growing season and soil: frost dates, rainfall patterns, and what the soil is. USDA and extension resources, plus a soil test, will tell you more than a travel brochure’s “mild winters.” A short season is not a defect if your plan fits it. It is a defect if your plan is copied from a longer one.

Zoning and livestock: the county, and sometimes the town, decide hens, goats, slaughter, outbuildings, and whether a second dwelling is even thinkable. A “farmy” listing in a residential zone is a regular disappointment.

Access and work: year-round road access, distance to a job or a market, distance to a veterinarian and a hardware store, and whether you can get insurance. Isolation is a cost, not only an aesthetic.

Money: purchase price is one line. Taxes, insurance, fencing, water, septic, and the first winter’s hay or the first season’s irrigation are others. We will not invent typical prices. You will have to collect local quotes.

Rules that are easy to miss: floodplains, fire zones, conservation easements, HOA covenants on land that does not look like a subdivision, and food-sales rules if you hope to sell a surplus.

A comparison table you can photocopy

Use one column per county or property, not one column per state.

Criterion What “good enough” might look like Official or primary source A false comfort
Water A legal, documented supply that matches the household and the garden or stock you plan, in a dry year as well as a wet one State water agency, well logs, irrigation district, county health “There’s a stream at the bottom of the pasture”
Season and soil Crops and animals that match the frost dates and the soil test Local Extension, USDA soil information, a lab test A seed catalog photograph from another region
Zoning and animals Written confirmation of the species, numbers, and structures you intend County planning and animal control, not a seller’s shrug A listing that uses the word “homestead” as decoration
Access A road you can use in the worst month you will actually live there County roads office, a visit in that month if you can A summer Sunday drive
Work and services Time to a job, a clinic, a vet, and parts Your own measured drive; professional listings “We’ll only go to town once a month,” said before the first broken pump
Money A purchase you can fund after a realistic infrastructure list County tax and assessor records, insurer quotes, contractor quotes The asking price alone
Fire, flood, wind A risk you understand and can insure and manage Official hazard maps and emergency-management pages A cheap parcel with no one willing to insure it
Selling food, if that is the plan A path that exists in that state for your product State agriculture and health departments Assuming a farm stand is an unregulated right

If two states both look possible, do this table for one county in each, not for the states as a whole. States are large. Counties decide the week you will actually have.

A buying sequence that wastes less travel

  1. Write the homestead you mean: garden only, a few animals, or a business. The “best” place has to match that list.
  2. Shortlist regions for climate and for work, using official climate and labor-market information, not a ranking video.
  3. Call or read county planning, environmental health, and extension, with a specific parcel or a specific township in mind.
  4. Walk the land in a boring season. Look at access, neighbors, drainage, and the state of any well or fence the price depends on.
  5. Price the missing infrastructure before you bargain as if the land were already finished.
  6. Have a lawyer and, if needed, a water or septic professional look at the documents. This is part of the cost of buying, not an optional feeling.

If, after all that, a particular state keeps showing up, it is “best” for you because it survived the checklist. That is the only ranking we trust.

A checklist to put in the folder with the parcel map

  • I have described the homestead in jobs and animals, not in slogans
  • Water is documented, not assumed
  • Zoning for those animals and buildings is confirmed in writing
  • I have spoken with or read the local Extension office
  • I have visited, or I have a hard plan to visit, outside peak weather
  • Insurance and taxes have quotes or official figures, not guesses
  • I will not make an offer on the strength of a national “best states” list

Questions buyers ask when they still want a shortlist

So which states are the best, in brief?

The brief answer is: the ones where water, zoning, season, work, and money all fit the homestead you intend to run. Any list that ignores those columns is entertainment. A rural county in a “popular” state can be a worse fit than a less fashionable county with better water and clearer rules.

Is a cheap land tax or a cheap acre always a good sign?

It can be a sign of modest services, difficult land, a remote location, or a bargain. You will not know which until you add insurance, access, and the cost of making the place livable. Cheap acres that need a road, a well, and a barn are not cheap.

What if I work remotely and can pick any state?

You can pick any region your internet, your insurance, and your visa or tax situation allow, and you still cannot pick any parcel. Water and zoning do not become optional because your job is elsewhere.

How does Washington state, or any other specific state, enter this?

The same way: county by county, with official pages open. “Homesteading in Washington state” is a cluster of different climates and different county codes, not one answer. Repeat the table for the county you would actually buy in.

Tags: #homesteading#land buying#US states#zoning#beginning farmers